Assorted Afflatuses

From Assorted Afflatuses

Statistical Lies

By Joseph on 20 December 2006 | Permalink

A story on the BBC recently caught my attention, not because it revealed anything particularly alarming, but rather because it contained a strange analysis of statistics. The article, "One in 20 Latinos 'goes hungry,'" details the findings of a new report, released today by the National Council of La Raza. According to the article, the new report claims that one in every twenty Hispanics living in the United States regularly lacks food. The article goes on to comment that such a rate, "is substantially greater than that of non-Hispanic whites," citing a government statistic, which puts hunger rate of non-Hispanic whites at 5%.

That analysis makes absolutely no sense. If the National Council of La Raza claims that one in every twenty Hispanics is hungry, then it could be said that five in every hundred — or five percent of — Hispanics are, unfortunately, hungry. How remarkable: the same percentage of non-Hispanic whites and Hispanic whites are hungry, according to these two sources.

And this is why, my readers dear, statistics lie: dare not go near!

4 Comments

Leland
20 December 06 at 23:55 (GMT -08:00)

A very good point, Joseph.

Anonymous
22 December 06 at 22:16 (GMT -08:00)

Good point, journalists can be quite silly, but Kibe, you spelled Statistical incorrectly...

Joseph Kibe
22 December 06 at 22:25 (GMT -08:00)

In my defense, I have never been a very good speller. Granted, in this case I see that more as a typo than a spelling problem.

Anonymous
30 December 06 at 00:36 (GMT -08:00)

Lies , Damned Lies , and Statistics . Point of View is crucial .

Leave a comment

Powered by Movable Type