How to Write a Textbook

By Joseph Kibe on 12 May 2009 6:48 PM

I have devoted so much time on my blog to bashing textbooks I thought it was time to lavish one with praise.

While I cringed at the cash register when I paid for Miklós Bóna's "Introduction to Enumerative Combinatorics," I have few qualms with contents of the (overpriced) volume. Unlike most textbooks, which dumb down the material with colorful pictures and so-called "real-word applications" in cute colored boxes, this textbook dishes the concepts out straight. It is to most textbooks what a shot of espresso is to a double soy chai chocolate cinnamon lemon ginger latte with whipped cream.

The author also has a subtle sense of humor that permeates the explanations, examples and exercises. Take this gem from page 83:

Let us revisit our friends on the canoe trip whose travails we discussed in Chapter 1. Undaunted by the problems last summer, they are going on a trip again. We hear that this excursion also turns out to be eventful. To be more precise, we hear that five of them fell into the water at one point or another, while nine of them saw their breakfast stolen by raccoons. None of the friends on the trip managed to escape either of these two experiences. How many friends went on the canoe trip this year?

It's not quite as entertaining as a performance by the local improv troupe. It is, however, far better than a dry example involving boxes and tokens of various colors, or an example that tries too hard by including gnomes, unicorns and other fanciful — but entirely unfunny — creatures and features.

As a relatively new text, the book does have a few typos here and there. But these do not outweigh the benefit provided by the clarity of writing, lack of superfluous fluff and colorful style. If the publisher knocked about $150 off the price tag, it would be perfect.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://www.kibeland.com/cms/mt-tb.cgi/278

Leave a comment